Is trade still possible between two nations if they have identical production possibilities curves? Explain with the help of a diagram
Yes, trade is still possible between two nations even if they have identical production possibilities curves (PPCs).
Get the full solved assignment PDF of MEC-107 of 2023-24 session now by clicking on above button.
To understand this, it’s important to explore the concept of comparative advantage and how it can facilitate trade, even when the production capabilities of two countries are identical.
Comparative Advantage
The key to understanding this scenario lies in the principle of comparative advantage. Even if two countries have identical PPCs, they can still benefit from trade if they have different opportunity costs for producing different goods. Comparative advantage occurs when a country has a lower opportunity cost in the production of a good compared to another country.
Diagram and Explanation
Here’s a step-by-step explanation with a diagram:
1. Identical PPCs
- Production Possibilities Curve (PPC): Suppose both Country A and Country B have identical PPCs. This means they have the same maximum output combinations for two goods, say Good X and Good Y, given their resources and technology.
- Diagram 1: Two identical PPCs.
Good Y | PPC | /| | / | | / | | / | | / | | / | | / | | / | | / | |/_________| Good X - Both countries can produce a combination of Good X and Good Y within the boundary of their PPCs.
2. Different Opportunity Costs
- Opportunity Cost: Even with identical PPCs, each country might have different opportunity costs for producing Good X and Good Y. For instance, the amount of Good Y that must be forgone to produce an additional unit of Good X might be different in each country.
- Suppose Country A has a comparative advantage in producing Good X (it sacrifices less Good Y to produce Good X compared to Country B).
- Conversely, Country B has a comparative advantage in producing Good Y.
3. Specialization and Trade
- Specialization: Each country specializes in producing the good for which it has a comparative advantage. This specialization allows each country to produce more efficiently.
- Country A: Specializes in Good X.
- Country B: Specializes in Good Y.
- Trade: After specialization, the countries trade to obtain the goods they are less efficient at producing.
- Diagram 2: Trade and Specialization.
Good Y | Country A (Specializing in Good X) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / |_________/_________ Good X | Country B (Specializing in Good Y)After specializing, each country can trade with the other to obtain the goods they need.
4. Benefits of Trade
- Gains from Trade: Through trade, both countries can end up with more of both goods than they would have been able to produce on their own.
- Diagram 3: Post-Trade Consumption.
Good Y | Pre-Trade | /| | / | | / | | / | | / | Post-Trade | / | | / | |_____/_______| Good X- Pre-Trade: Each country consumes within its PPC.
- Post-Trade: Each country can consume beyond its PPC by trading.
Conclusion
Even if two countries have identical PPCs, trade can still be beneficial if they have different opportunity costs for producing goods. By specializing based on comparative advantage and trading, both countries can achieve higher overall levels of consumption and benefit from trade. The identical PPCs illustrate that both countries have the same potential production capabilities, but comparative advantage and opportunity costs drive the trade benefits.