Critically examine the relative merits and demerits of the fixed and flexible exchange rates

Critically examine the relative merits and demerits of the fixed and flexible exchange rates

Exchange rate systems are crucial in determining how currencies are valued relative to one another.

Get the full solved assignment PDF of MEC-007 of 2023-24 session now by clicking on above button.

There are two primary types of exchange rate systems: fixed (or pegged) exchange rates and flexible (or floating) exchange rates. Each system has its own advantages and disadvantages. Here’s a critical examination of both:

Fixed Exchange Rates

Definition: In a fixed exchange rate system, a country’s currency value is pegged or fixed to another major currency (like the U.S. dollar or the euro) or a basket of currencies. The central bank intervenes in the foreign exchange market to maintain the currency’s value within a narrow band.

Merits:

1. Stability and Predictability:

• Reduced Volatility: Fixed exchange rates provide stability in international prices and exchange rates, which helps in reducing uncertainty for international trade and investment.
• Encourages Trade: Stability encourages international trade and investment by reducing the risk of exchange rate fluctuations.

1. Inflation Control:

• Discipline: By pegging to a stable currency, countries can import the credibility of the anchor currency’s monetary policy, which can help control domestic inflation.

1. Credibility:

• Anchor Currency: The fixed rate provides a clear and predictable policy framework, which can enhance investor confidence and stabilize capital flows.

1. Automatic Adjustment:

• External Balance: If the fixed rate is credible, it can help in achieving external balance by adjusting domestic policies in line with international competitiveness.

Demerits:

1. Loss of Monetary Policy Independence:

• Policy Constraints: Countries with fixed exchange rates often sacrifice their ability to pursue independent monetary policies. They must align their monetary policy with that of the currency to which their currency is pegged.

1. Vulnerability to Speculative Attacks:

• Risk of Crisis: If the fixed rate is perceived as unsustainable, it can lead to speculative attacks, forcing the country to devalue or abandon the peg.

1. Adjustment Costs:

• Rigidities: Adjusting to economic shocks can be costly and difficult, as the fixed rate does not automatically adjust to changes in economic conditions or trade imbalances.

1. Foreign Exchange Reserves:

• High Cost: Maintaining a fixed exchange rate requires large foreign exchange reserves to manage the currency’s value, which can be a burden on the country’s finances.

Flexible Exchange Rates

Definition: In a flexible or floating exchange rate system, currency values are determined by market forces without direct government or central bank intervention. Exchange rates fluctuate based on supply and demand in the foreign exchange market.

Merits:

1. Monetary Policy Independence:

• Policy Flexibility: Countries with flexible exchange rates can pursue independent monetary policies suited to their own economic conditions without having to maintain a fixed exchange rate.

1. Automatic Adjustment Mechanism:

• Self-Correction: Exchange rates adjust automatically to changes in economic conditions, trade imbalances, and capital flows, which can help in achieving external balance without the need for direct intervention.

1. Reduced Speculative Pressure:

• Market-Based: With no fixed peg to defend, countries are less vulnerable to speculative attacks. The market determines the value of the currency, reducing the pressure on central banks.

1. Resource Allocation:

• Market Signals: Flexible exchange rates provide accurate signals about the relative value of currencies, which helps in the efficient allocation of resources and adjustment to economic shocks.

Demerits:

1. Exchange Rate Volatility:

• Uncertainty: Floating exchange rates can lead to greater volatility and uncertainty in currency values, which may affect international trade and investment.

1. Inflation Risk:

• Potential for Inflation: Exchange rate fluctuations can lead to inflationary pressures if the domestic currency depreciates significantly.

1. Speculative Behavior:

• Market Sentiment: While less prone to speculative attacks than fixed systems, floating rates can still be affected by speculative behavior and market sentiment, leading to short-term volatility.

1. Policy Challenges:

• Adjustment Costs: The automatic adjustment mechanism may not always align with desired economic outcomes, and the resulting fluctuations can create economic instability.

Summary

Fixed Exchange Rates offer stability and predictability, which can facilitate trade and control inflation but come at the cost of monetary policy independence and potential vulnerability to crises. Flexible Exchange Rates provide monetary policy flexibility and automatic adjustment to economic conditions but can lead to exchange rate volatility and uncertainty.

The choice between fixed and flexible exchange rates depends on a country’s economic goals, policy preferences, and external economic conditions. Many countries opt for a hybrid approach, using managed floats or targeting inflation while allowing some degree of exchange rate flexibility.