Illustrate some applications of ‘mechanism design’ with an identification of their attendant problems
Mechanism design has various applications across different domains.
Get the full solved assignment PDF of MEC-106 of 2023-24 session now by clicking on above button.
Here are some illustrative examples along with the attendant problems:
1. Auctions
Application: Auctions are a classic example of mechanism design. They are used to allocate resources or goods to bidders based on their bids.
Types of Auctions:
- First-Price Auction: Bidders submit sealed bids, and the highest bidder wins, paying their bid amount.
- Second-Price Auction (Vickrey Auction): Bidders submit sealed bids, and the highest bidder wins but pays the second-highest bid amount.
Attendant Problems:
- Bidder Collusion: Bidders might collude to drive down prices or share information, leading to inefficient outcomes.
- Winner’s Curse: In common-value auctions (where the item’s value is the same for all but unknown), the winning bidder may overpay due to overestimation of the value.
- Strategic Bidding: In a first-price auction, bidders may shade their bids to avoid overpaying, which can lead to inefficient allocations.
2. Public Goods Provision
Application: Mechanisms are designed to fund and provide public goods (like national defense, public parks) through contributions or taxation.
Mechanism: Clark-Groves Mechanism is used to incentivize truthfully revealing private valuations of the public good.
Attendant Problems:
- Free-Rider Problem: Individuals may benefit from the public good without contributing, leading to under-provision.
- Information Asymmetry: Difficulty in accurately assessing individual valuations and contributions.
- Enforcement: Ensuring compliance and fair contributions can be challenging.
3. Matching Markets
Application: Mechanisms are used to match agents in various markets, such as students to schools, doctors to hospitals, or buyers to sellers.
Mechanism: Gale-Shapley Deferred Acceptance Algorithm is used for matching students to schools or medical residents to hospitals.
Attendant Problems:
- Stability vs. Efficiency: While the Gale-Shapley algorithm is stable, it may not always result in the most efficient matches. For example, stable matches might be less optimal from a social welfare perspective.
- Strategic Manipulation: Participants might misrepresent their preferences to achieve a better outcome.
4. Healthcare Rationing
Application: Mechanisms are designed to allocate scarce healthcare resources, such as organ transplants or medical treatments, among patients.
Mechanism: Allocation Algorithms used for prioritizing patients based on factors like urgency, prognosis, and equity.
Attendant Problems:
- Equity vs. Efficiency: Balancing fairness and efficiency can be difficult. Ensuring equitable access while optimizing resource use is a complex challenge.
- Ethical Concerns: Deciding who gets priority can raise ethical issues and may be subject to public scrutiny.
5. Corporate Governance
Application: Mechanisms are designed to align the interests of managers and shareholders to maximize company value.
Mechanism: Incentive Contracts tie managerial compensation to company performance metrics such as stock price or profitability.
Attendant Problems:
- Short-Termism: Managers might focus on short-term gains to maximize their bonuses, potentially at the expense of long-term company health.
- Performance Measurement: Designing performance metrics that accurately reflect managerial performance and avoid manipulation can be challenging.
6. Regulation and Environmental Policy
Application: Mechanisms are designed to regulate environmental impacts, such as pollution, by setting standards or creating trading schemes.
Mechanism: Cap-and-Trade Systems limit the total level of pollution and allow firms to trade emission permits.
Attendant Problems:
- Permit Allocation: How permits are allocated (e.g., auctioned vs. grandfathered) can affect the effectiveness and fairness of the system.
- Market Manipulation: Firms might manipulate permit prices or hoard permits to gain market advantages.
Conclusion
Mechanism design offers powerful tools for solving a range of allocation and incentive problems. However, each application comes with its own set of challenges, including issues related to collusion, strategic behavior, fairness, and practical implementation. Addressing these problems often requires careful consideration of both theoretical design and real-world constraints.